What does the travel industry need to stop doing — including your own part of it?
“It needs to stop assuming that success in tourism, as measured in national economic metrics, translates into success of the places where tourism happens. This has been the great assumption of the travel industry and has been the driving impetus for governments investing in tourism development.
However, there’s a growing recognition that it’s not an automatic process and that one doesn’t necessarily lead to the other. There is more intention now about leveraging local value from tourism activity.
We need to change the way we measure tourism success and focus our metrics not only on national economic metrics, but also on local metrics that tell us about the vitality of the places where tourism happens. Is nature healthier? Are local livelihoods more secure? Do young people see a bright future through tourism? Is cultural identity strong? Do local people feel involved and that they have a say? Do they celebrate tourism or just tolerate it? Is the tourism economy generating value that stays in the local community?
People can dismiss these as soft metrics but I regard them as the hard ones. Not that they are harder to collect (that just takes the will to do it), but more that they are harder to read, discuss and negotiate.
One of the challenges is that we are now asking tourism leaders to deliver outcomes for nature, culture, communities and long-term resilience, often having spent their careers being measured and rewarded for economic growth. The mandate has changed, yet the measures and systems around them haven’t kept pace.
My own part? I’ve stood on stages helping make “regenerative” engaging and understandable. After one such talk, a senior leader once said to me, “I buy in hook, line and sinker, but I still have a policy to implement.” The only language I had that day cast his model as bad and mine as good, and it was no help to anyone.
I think the regenerative tourism philosophy has done a great deal to advance the thinking. In future, I’d like to focus my own energy on helping people apply it, within the realities and constraints of the organisations they lead. I try to recognise that we are in a period of navigation now and that it’s about enabling the journey to commence, rather than wanting to arrive quickly at the end point.”
Name one place that changed how you think about travel. What happened there?
“The Burren, in the west of Ireland, not too far from where I live right now.
I moved to this area more or less on instinct around the time my children were born. I had no particular intention to work in tourism, but a part-time job after an extended period of maternity leave brought me into it.
The Burren itself is an extraordinary landscape of limestone, wildflowers, ancient monuments, farming traditions and small communities. It has an austere beauty and is a very spiritual place as well as a great natural wilderness in places.
Many people feel passionately about caring for the place and it’s also a protected landscape. So talk of tourism has always been less straightforward there.
The main thing it taught me was seeing that people on every side of a tourism argument were moved by the same thing: love of the place. Those who wanted more tourism wanted it so the place would thrive and those who didn’t want tourism didn’t want it because they wanted the place to thrive.
I often say you can’t get everyone on the same page until you identify the page. The Burren taught me that place is the page. That realisation really shaped the rest of my work in tourism.
Apart from that, it’s a vibrant and fun place to be whatever the weather and the season. Spending time there really does revive the mind and the spirit.
I think this is something particularly valuable about tourism today. In a world where so much of life is becoming virtual and where people can become increasingly disconnected from the real world, tourism brings us out into it. We get to experience real landscapes, people, cultures and ways of living. There is enormous potential in that, not only for the places we visit, but for us as people too.”